Limits to international estimates of stroke costs.

نویسندگان

  • Ronald B Low
  • Adnan I Qureshi
  • David C Low
چکیده

See related article, pages 319–324. Lundstrom et al show a marked increase in cost of caring for patients with stroke with spasticity compared with the cost of caring for patients with stroke without spasticity.1 This is an important contribution to our understanding of stroke and its costs. If a reader attempts to generalize Lundström et al’s findings to other countries, we see 2 important limitations that are not clear in their article: treatment of spasticity and using Purchasing Power Parities (PPPs) to estimate costs in other countries. First, the spastic patients in their study were not treated pharmacologically for spasticity. Their patients were not treated with botulism toxin (Botox) or even dantrolene, baclofen, or benzodiazepines. Had the spasticity been treated, the costs might have been lower. Second, Lundström projects the costs to countries outside of Sweden by converting costs in Swedish Krona to adjusted costs in other countries, in their currency, by multiplying Swedish costs by a PPP multiplier (Lundstrom et al’s supplemental Table I). PPP is used by economists to adjust for cost of living. We would not need PPP if most word trade involved easily (relatively cheaply) transported, nonperishable items such as cameras or CT scanners; the cost of an expensive SLR camera in Stockholm will be pretty close to the cost of the same camera bought in New York after converting the currency from dollars to Krona. Many costs of daily living are more perishable and less easily transported: buying a meal, renting an apartment, getting medical care, or having hair cut. To adjust for cost of living in different parts of the world, economists in different regions buy a market basket of food, shelter, a haircut, and other common purchases needed for living. Healthcare costs are a very small part of this PPP market basket. From the costs of items in this market basket, economists calculate PPP. With tongue partly in cheek, economists sometimes use an even simpler index that looks only at purchasing food: the “Big Mac Index,” a “market basket” of one item, a McDonald’s Big Mac.2 Health expenses track differently from the overall cost of the PPP market basket. Comparatively, a Big Mac is reasonably priced in the United States and Canada; health care is expensive. We have reproduced data from supplemental Table I of their article for 6 countries. We have added 4 new columns: exchange rate, Big Mac Index,2 and stroke (spastic and not) costs converted back to dollars. The Big Mac Index is the cost, in US dollars, of a Big Mac in that country. Additionally, for each adjusted stroke cost in local currency, we converted those costs to US dollars. To calculate stroke costs in dollars, we used the exchange rate on January 30, 2009, taken from the same article in The Economist that reported the Big Mac Index.2 We note that although the methods of calculating costs differ, the stroke costs for Denmark projected by Lundström seem higher than costs actually measured recently ($12 150/patient in direct costs for all strokes).3 Denmark’s economy resembles Sweden’s in many ways; we would anticipate even greater disparity between real costs and those modeled on supplemental Table I for the United States and other countries with medical economies that differ more markedly from Sweden’s. Because of the PPP conversion, Lundström’s supplemental Table I suggests that stroke care costs in the United States and Canada are relatively inexpensive, whereas we know that those 2 countries actually have comparatively high healthcare costs. If we used exchange rates from late 2009, which reflect the recent devaluation of the US dollar, there would be an even greater disparity between real costs for caring for strokes in the United States and the costs projected by Lundstrom’s method. International comparison of healthcare costs is desirable; a tool for adjusting by cost of living would be helpful. Using PPP to adjust healthcare costs does not seem helpful. Pharmacological treatment of spasticity might be beneficial for many reasons.

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

The Economic Burden of Stroke Based on South Korea’s National Health Insurance Claims Database

Background This study was conducted to determine the scale and the nature of the economic burden caused by strokes and to use the results as an evidential source for determining the allocation of South Korea stroke cases in 2015.   Methods For research subjects, the study analyzed demographic characteristics and economic burden based on data from national health insurance (NHI) claims for inpat...

متن کامل

Patient-level costs of major cardiovascular conditions: a review of the international literature

OBJECTIVE Robust cost estimates of cardiovascular (CV) events are required for assessing health care interventions aimed at reducing the economic burden of major adverse CV events. This review synthesizes international cost estimates of CV events. METHODS MEDLINE database was searched electronically for English language studies published during 2007-2012, with cost estimates for CV events of ...

متن کامل

A New Algorithm for Determining Ultimate Pit Limits Based on Network Optimization

One of the main concerns of the mining industry is to determine ultimate pit limits. Final pit is a collection of blocks, which can be removed with maximum profit while following restrictions on the slope of the mine’s walls. The size, location and final shape of an open-pit are very important in designing the location of waste dumps, stockpiles, processing plants, access roads and other surfac...

متن کامل

Costs of stroke using patient-level data: a critical review of the literature.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE With decision-analytic models becoming more popular to assess the cost-effectiveness of health care interventions, the need for robust estimates on the costs of cerebrovascular disease is paramount. This study reports the results from a literature review of the costs of cerebrovascular diseases, and assesses the quality of the published evidence against a set of defined c...

متن کامل

Analysis of the costs and payments of a coordinated stroke center and regional stroke network.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE An earlier study demonstrated significantly improved access, treatment, and outcomes after the implementation of a progressive, comprehensive stroke program at a tertiary care community hospital, Saint Luke's Neuroscience Institute (SLNI). This study evaluated the costs associated with implementing such a program. METHODS Retrospective analysis of total hospital costs a...

متن کامل

Optimal Process Adjustment with Considering Variable Costs for Uni-variate and Multi-variate Production Process (RESEARCH NOTE)

This paper studies a single-stage production system, two-stage production system where specification limits are designed for inspection. When quality characteristics fall below a lower threshold or above an upper threshold, a decision is made to rework or scrap the item. The target is to determine the optimum target for a process based on rework or scrap costs. In contrast to previous studies, ...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

عنوان ژورنال:
  • Stroke

دوره 41 2  شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 2010